Article image

The Forty-Day Freeze

Monday, 10 November 2025 01:31

Summary

The 2025 US federal government shutdown, which began on October 1, 2025, became the longest in the nation's history, stretching over 40 days and furloughing nearly a million federal employees1,2. The crisis was rooted in a political deadlock over the extension of Affordable Care Act (ACA) subsidies, which Democrats demanded and the Republican-controlled House and President Donald Trump resisted3,4. The resulting funding lapse crippled government operations, leading to widespread flight cancellations, a threat to food assistance for millions, and a disruption of pay for local workers at US military bases overseas5,6,7. A tentative Senate deal, brokered by a bipartisan group of moderates, emerged to end the impasse, proposing a short-term funding extension until late January and a guaranteed vote on the contentious ACA subsidies in December8,9. The resolution, while offering a temporary reprieve, underscored the deep, structural polarisation of the US political system and the increasing weaponisation of the appropriations process10.

The Anatomy of a Record-Breaking Impasse

The 2025 federal government shutdown commenced at midnight Eastern Daylight Time on October 1, marking the beginning of the 2026 fiscal year without the necessary appropriations legislation in place1,11. This funding lapse was the 11th to result in federal employee furloughs since 1980, but it quickly surpassed all predecessors to become the longest in US history, eclipsing the 35-day shutdown of 2018–20191,12. The core of the political deadlock centred on the expiration of critical subsidies for health plans offered under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace3,4. These subsidies, which had been temporarily expanded by the Inflation Reduction Act, were set to lapse at the end of the year, a change that was projected to cause premiums to more than double for those enrolled in the health exchanges4,13. Senate Democrats, led by Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, made the extension of these subsidies a non-negotiable condition for passing any continuing resolution (CR) to fund the government3,14. Conversely, President Donald Trump and many Republicans advocated for gutting the ACA subsidies entirely, with the President suggesting money should be sent directly to individuals instead of insurance companies15. The Republican-controlled House of Representatives passed a continuing resolution that did not include the subsidy extension, a measure the Senate rejected 14 times, largely along party lines1,3. The impasse was further intensified by the Trump administration’s revival of 'rescissions,' a mechanism used to permanently codify cuts to appropriated parts of the federal government, including nearly $5 billion in foreign aid1,16. This move was seen by some as an attempt to force through the administration's agenda of health care cuts and higher prices17.

The Crippling Domestic Toll

The protracted funding crisis inflicted immediate and widespread damage across the US economy and public services18. Approximately 900,000 federal employees were furloughed, while another two million, deemed 'excepted' or essential, were required to continue working without pay1,19. The first missed pay date for some federal workers occurred on October 24, with others following shortly after20. Although a 2019 law guarantees back pay for furloughed and excepted employees once the government reopens, the administration had indicated it might not honour the requirement for furloughed workers, adding to the financial anxiety21,22. The disruption extended to critical infrastructure, most notably air travel5. As thousands of air traffic controllers and security screeners worked without pay, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) began cutting flights at 40 major US airports5,23. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy announced that flight cuts, initially at 4 per cent, were set to increase to 10 per cent at major hubs like Atlanta, Chicago, and Los Angeles, leading to mounting chaos and widespread cancellations5,24. The shutdown also threatened the nation's most vulnerable populations6. Food assistance programs, including the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and the Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) program, faced funding uncertainty1,6. The potential lapse of SNAP and WIC benefits for November prompted food bank non-profit organisations across the country, particularly in the Washington, D.C. area, to prepare for an influx of people set to lose their benefits1,6. The economic fallout was severe, with economists warning that if the shutdown continued much longer, the country’s economic growth could turn negative in the fourth quarter15.

Global Repercussions and Military Strain

The political paralysis in Washington had tangible consequences far beyond the nation's borders, particularly for the US military's global footprint25. While active-duty service members were required to continue their duties, they were not receiving pay, with November 14 projected to be the first time in history that members of all military branches would miss a paycheck due to a government shutdown20,26. The Department of Defense and the Transportation Security Administration were among the agencies that continued to operate, but military and civilian workers were still affected1,27. The most immediate and acute impact was felt by local national employees at US military bases overseas7. In Europe, at least 2,000 local workers at US bases had their salaries interrupted for nearly six weeks7,28. These foreign nationals perform essential roles ranging from food service and maintenance to logistics and construction7. In Italy and Portugal, workers at bases like Aviano Air Base and Lajes Field continued to work unpaid, with union coordinators describing the situation as 'absurd' and having 'dramatic effects' on their members7,29. In a stark contrast, the German government intervened to pay the salaries of nearly 11,000 local civilian employees working on US military bases, including the critical Ramstein Air Base7,30. The pay disruption for these foreign nationals, many of whom are contractors not covered by US back pay laws, created significant financial hardship and strained diplomatic relations with host nations7,31.

The Path to a Temporary Truce

As the shutdown entered its sixth week, pressure from the mounting domestic and international crises finally spurred a breakthrough in the Senate8,32. A tentative, bipartisan deal emerged from negotiations led by a small group of moderate senators, including Jeanne Shaheen, Maggie Hassan, and Independent Angus King8,9. The proposed agreement, which Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) said was 'coming together,' represented a significant concession from the Republican side9,14. The deal included a continuing resolution to fund the majority of the government until January 308,10. Crucially, it also included full-year appropriations bills for three areas: Military Construction and Veterans Affairs, the Legislative Branch, and the Department of Agriculture and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)10,33. The most significant political victory for Democrats was the inclusion of a guaranteed vote in the Senate on the extension of the Affordable Care Act subsidies, scheduled for December8,10. This provision allowed Democrats to claim a win by securing a vote on their central demand, even if the final outcome of that vote remained uncertain14. Furthermore, the deal included provisions to reinstate all federal employees who had been fired after the shutdown began, restoring their jobs with back pay, and ensuring that food stamps would be funded through the 2026 fiscal year10,34. Despite the progress, the deal faced immediate resistance from some Democrats, including Senator Bernie Sanders, who warned against 'caving in to Trump' without a firm guarantee on the health care subsidies14,35. The amended package still required passage in both the Senate and the House of Representatives before it could be sent to President Trump for his signature, a process that was expected to take several days10,36.

Conclusion

The 40-day shutdown of 2025 served as a profound demonstration of the fragility inherent in the US government’s funding mechanism when confronted by extreme political polarisation1,12. The crisis was not merely a bureaucratic inconvenience but a national and international emergency that left millions of citizens and foreign partners in precarious financial positions5,7. The eventual, tentative resolution, which punted the most contentious issue—the future of the Affordable Care Act subsidies—into the following month, highlighted a pattern of legislative crisis management rather than structural reform8,10. While the immediate threat of a continued shutdown was averted, the underlying political dynamics that allowed a single policy dispute to paralyse the entire federal apparatus remained unresolved3,14. The episode confirmed that the appropriations process had become a primary battleground for ideological warfare, with the livelihoods of federal workers, the stability of critical services, and the nation's global standing serving as collateral18,25. The temporary truce merely set the stage for the next confrontation, ensuring that the specter of another, potentially longer, shutdown would continue to loom over Washington10.

References

  1. 2025 United States federal government shutdown - Wikipedia

    Supports the start date, duration, number of furloughed employees, the cause (failure to pass appropriations for FY 2026), the number of times the CR was rejected, and the agencies affected.

  2. US government shutdown reaches its 40th day as senators work through crucial weekend

    Confirms the 40-day duration and the ongoing work by senators to find a resolution.

  3. Senate leader says a potential shutdown deal is coming together but there's no guarantee of success | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

    Details the core conflict over the Affordable Care Act subsidies and the Democrats' demand for their extension.

  4. Democrats Consider GOP Deal to Reopen Government With Promise for Later Vote on Health-Care Tax Credits - Mississippi Free Press

    Explains the impact of the ACA subsidies lapsing (premiums doubling) and the Democrats' position.

  5. Senators negotiate over shutdown as furor grows over flight cuts, SNAP. Live updates:

    Provides details on the impact on air travel, including flight delays, cancellations, the role of air traffic controllers, and the Transportation Secretary's order for flight cuts at major airports.

  6. US government shutdown reaches its 40th day as senators work through crucial weekend

    Mentions the threat to food assistance for millions of Americans and the impact on federal workers' pay.

  7. US government shutdown forces local workers at some overseas bases to go without pay

    Details the impact on local workers at overseas US military bases in Europe, including the number of affected workers, the situation in Italy and Portugal, and Germany's intervention.

  8. Senate nears potential shutdown deal but there's no guarantee of success - Colorado Politics

    Describes the tentative deal brokered by moderate senators, the funding extension until late January, and the promise of a later vote on health care subsidies.

  9. Senate leader says a potential shutdown deal is coming together but there's no guarantee of success | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

    Confirms Senate Majority Leader John Thune's statement that a deal was 'coming together' and the involvement of moderate Democrats.

  10. Government shutdown over? Inside Senate's deal to extend funding. What's next?

    Provides specific details of the final deal: funding until Jan. 30, full-year appropriations for three bills, guaranteed vote on ACA subsidies in December, reinstatement of fired employees with back pay, and funding for food stamps.

  11. 2025 United States federal government shutdown - Wikipedia

    Confirms the start date of the shutdown (October 1, 2025) and the fiscal year it affected (2026).

  12. Government shutdowns in the United States - Wikipedia

    Provides historical context, confirming the 2025 shutdown was the longest and detailing previous significant shutdowns.

  13. Trump takes aim at Obamacare as historic federal shutdown hits 40th day | KSL.com

    Confirms the ACA subsidies were at the heart of the shutdown and their role in doubling enrollment.

  14. Senate vote today: First details on shutdown deal out; Republicans, Democrats hopeful of breakthrough | Hindustan Times

    Details Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer's position and the resistance from some Democrats to the deal.

  15. Trump takes aim at Obamacare as historic federal shutdown hits 40th day | KSL.com

    Supports President Trump's stance on the ACA subsidies and the warning about negative economic growth.

  16. 2025 United States federal government shutdown - Wikipedia

    Details the Trump administration's use of rescissions to cut foreign aid.

  17. 2025 Government Shutdown | Congressman Greg Stanton

    Provides the perspective that the administration was trying to force through an agenda of health care cuts.

  18. How the Federal Workforce is Impacted During a Government Shutdown (2025 Update)

    Supports the general impact on the federal workforce and the curtailing of public benefits and services.

  19. 2025 United States federal government shutdown - Wikipedia

    Confirms the number of furloughed and working-without-pay employees.

  20. Who Is Missing Paychecks in the 2025 Shutdown—When and Where? - Bipartisan Policy Center

    Provides the date of the first missed paycheck and the potential date for active-duty military to miss a paycheck.

  21. 2025 United States federal government shutdown - Wikipedia

    Mentions the Government Employee Fair Treatment Act of 2019 and its back pay guarantee.

  22. How the Federal Workforce is Impacted During a Government Shutdown (2025 Update)

    Notes the administration's indication that it may not honour the back pay requirement for furloughed workers.

  23. Deal to end shutdown gains traction in US Senate as vote nears | News From The States

    Confirms air traffic controllers and security screeners were working without pay and the FAA began cutting flights.

  24. Senators negotiate over shutdown as furor grows over flight cuts, SNAP. Live updates:

    Provides the specific flight cut percentages and the major airports affected.

  25. US government shutdown forces some overseas bases to stop paying workers - WZDX

    Supports the general statement about the international impact and the pay disruption for local workers at overseas bases.

  26. Who Is Missing Paychecks in the 2025 Shutdown—When and Where? - Bipartisan Policy Center

    Confirms active-duty service members were required to work without pay and the date all branches were set to miss a paycheck.

  27. 2025 United States federal government shutdown - Wikipedia

    Confirms the Department of Defense and TSA continued to operate, but military and civilian workers were affected.

  28. US government shutdown forces some overseas bases to stop paying workers - Washington Times

    Confirms the number of local workers in Europe affected by salary interruptions.

  29. US government shutdown forces some overseas bases to stop paying workers - WZDX

    Provides quotes from the union coordinator at Aviano Air Base and details on the situation at Lajes Field in Portugal.

  30. US government shutdown forces some overseas bases to stop paying workers - WPXI

    Confirms the German government's intervention to pay nearly 11,000 local employees at US bases, including Ramstein.

  31. US government shutdown forces some overseas bases to stop paying workers - Washington Times

    Explains that contractors are most at-risk of losing pay and are not always covered by back pay laws.

  32. US Senate takes steps toward vote to end historic federal shutdown - The Guardian

    Confirms the Senate moved toward a vote to end the shutdown and the involvement of Senate Majority Leader John Thune.

  33. Senate leader says a potential shutdown deal is coming together but there's no guarantee of success | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

    Confirms the plan to approve full-year funding for several parts of the government.

  34. Government shutdown over? Inside Senate's deal to extend funding. What's next?

    Confirms the deal's provision to ensure food stamps are funded through fiscal year 2026.

  35. Government shutdown live updates as Thune plans Senate vote amid rare Sunday session

    Provides Senator Bernie Sanders' quote about the deal.

  36. US Senate takes steps toward vote to end historic federal shutdown - The Guardian

    Confirms the need for the amended package to pass both the House and Senate and be signed by the President.