Article image

The Last Sombre Exchange

Saturday, 08 November 2025 02:23

Summary

In a quiet, heavily secured exchange, the remains of the last known American hostage held in Gaza were transferred to Israeli forces. This event marks a poignant moment in the fragile ceasefire agreement brokered in October 2025. The process of returning the deceased has been a central, and often contentious, component of the truce's initial phase. For the family of the Israeli-American soldier, the return brings a painful closure after more than two years of uncertainty. The exchange unfolds against a backdrop of complex regional diplomacy, with the United States playing a significant role in the broader peace plan. Simultaneously, geopolitical tensions remain high, underscored by Turkey's issuance of arrest warrants for senior Israeli officials over the conduct of the war. The slow and arduous process of identifying and returning the remains of all hostages highlights the deep scars left by the conflict and the immense challenges that lie ahead in transforming a precarious truce into a lasting peace.

A Coffin Draped in a Flag

Under the watch of the International Committee of the Red Cross, a coffin was transferred from Hamas militants to Israeli forces in the Gaza Strip.31,32 This solemn event was part of an ongoing, US-brokered ceasefire agreement that commenced on 10 October 2025.10,23 The remains were then transported to the Abu Kabir National Center of Forensic Medicine in Tel Aviv for a formal identification process.29,31 Following forensic confirmation, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) announced the remains belonged to Staff Sergeant Itay Chen, a 19-year-old dual Israeli-US national.12,17 Chen was the last known American hostage whose remains were held in Gaza.12,24 He was killed on 7 October 2023, during the initial Hamas-led attack, and his body was taken into the besieged territory.12,17 The Israeli military had officially declared him deceased in March 2024, confirming he had died in combat.17 Upon receiving the coffin, IDF soldiers draped it in an Israeli flag and held a brief ceremony led by a military rabbi before escorting it into Israel.31,32

The Long Wait for Closure

For the family of Itay Chen, the return of his remains ended more than two years of agonising uncertainty.17 His parents, Ruby and Hagit Chen, had been prominent advocates for the return of all hostages.17 Hours before the handover, Ruby Chen expressed hope that the Israeli government would seize the opportunity presented by the ceasefire to complete the mission of bringing everyone home.17 His mother, Hagit, described the pain of their loss as "unbearable."17 The return of another Israeli-American soldier, Captain Omer Neutra, had occurred just days earlier.24,30 Neutra, who was 21 when he was killed on 7 October 2023, was raised on Long Island, New York, and had moved to Israel to volunteer in the military.23,43 His family had also campaigned tirelessly for his return, making numerous trips to Washington to lobby officials.23,43 For 14 months, they believed he was alive, until intelligence confirmed he had been killed during the attack.23,43 The funerals for these soldiers have drawn high-level attendance, including US officials, underscoring the significance of their dual nationality.23,26

The Mechanics of a Fragile Truce

The return of hostage remains is a central component of the first phase of a comprehensive peace plan.10,23 The ceasefire, which took effect in October 2025, stipulated the release of all living hostages in exchange for nearly 2,000 Palestinian prisoners and detainees.9,11 Hamas released the 20 remaining living hostages on 13 October 2025.10,23 The agreement also mandated that Hamas return the remains of all 28 deceased hostages.9 In return, Israel agreed to hand over the bodies of Palestinians.9,13 As of early November 2025, Israel had returned the bodies of 285 Palestinians to authorities in Gaza.10,25 The process has been fraught with challenges.14 Hamas has cited the massive destruction across Gaza as a significant hindrance to locating and recovering remains.9,11 This has led to accusations from Israeli officials that Hamas is violating the agreement by delaying the handovers.10,20 US officials, however, have urged patience, acknowledging the logistical difficulties and stating they did not believe Hamas had broken the agreement in bad faith.13,35 The deal requires that all deceased hostages are returned before negotiations can progress to subsequent phases, which include the reconstruction of Gaza and the establishment of a new governing body without Hamas.10,11,14

A Region on Edge

The exchange of remains occurred amid persistent regional tensions.3,4 On 7 November 2025, Turkey announced it had issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and 36 other senior Israeli officials, accusing them of genocide and crimes against humanity in Gaza.3,5 The list of officials included Defence Minister Israel Katz and National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir.5,6 The Istanbul prosecutor's office cited Israel's military actions, including the bombing of the Turkish-Palestinian Friendship Hospital in Gaza.4,5 Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar vehemently rejected the charges, calling them a "PR stunt" by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.3,4 The move by Turkey, a NATO member, complicates an already volatile geopolitical landscape.3 It also has implications for post-war planning in Gaza, as Turkey has expressed a desire to participate in a proposed international stabilisation force, a role Israel has rejected.6,47 The Islamist group Hamas welcomed Turkey's announcement as a "commendable measure."4,34

The Unseen Scars of Identification

Each handover initiates a meticulous and emotionally charged process of identification.29,31 The remains are taken to Israel's National Center of Forensic Medicine, where experts work to confirm the identity.24,32 This process can take several days.31 Once an identity is confirmed, representatives from the IDF and other state bodies personally inform the family before any public announcement is made.17,32 The return of remains is not always straightforward.22 In some instances, Hamas has returned partial remains or remains that did not match any of the listed hostages.10,22 On the other side of the exchange, the process is equally grim.9 Health officials in Gaza have struggled to identify the hundreds of bodies returned by Israel, hampered by decomposition and a lack of DNA testing kits.9,37 Many families in Gaza have resorted to trying to identify loved ones from fragments of clothing seen in photos posted online.9 The exchanges, while a core part of the ceasefire, continuously underscore the immense human cost of the conflict for all sides.9,37

Conclusion

The return of the last American's remains provides a sombre bookend to one of the most painful chapters of the Gaza war for the United States.12,24 It represents a tangible, albeit tragic, outcome of a complex diplomatic effort that forged a fragile ceasefire from the ruins of a devastating conflict.9,10 Yet, this moment of closure for one family is set against a landscape of unresolved issues.20 With the remains of several other hostages still in Gaza, the initial phase of the truce remains incomplete.22,33 The path forward hinges on navigating immense challenges, from the practical difficulties of recovery in a destroyed landscape to the deep-seated political mistrust between the warring parties.11,47 The broader geopolitical currents, including Turkey's legal challenge against Israel's leadership, further highlight the instability of the regional order.3,4 The quiet arrival of a single coffin is therefore more than a personal tragedy brought to its conclusion; it is a stark reminder of the precariousness of the current peace and the long, uncertain road ahead for a region still grappling with the echoes of war.47

References

  1. Current time information in غزة, PS

    Provides the current time in Gaza, which is relevant for establishing the temporal context of events described in the article, such as the timing of hostage remain transfers.

  2. Current time information in באר שבע, IL

    Provides the current time in Israel, which is relevant for establishing the temporal context of events described in the article, such as official announcements and forensic procedures.

  3. Turkey issues genocide arrest warrant against Israeli's Benjamin Netanyahu | RNZ News

    Reports on Turkey issuing arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other officials, providing crucial geopolitical context for the article. It includes Israel's official rejection of the charges.

  4. Turkey issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, other Israeli leaders over 'genocide' in Gaza

    Corroborates the news of Turkey's arrest warrants for Israeli officials, details the accusations of 'genocide and crimes against humanity,' and includes Hamas's supportive reaction.

  5. Middle East unrest: Turkey issues genocide arrest warrant against Netnayahu; Istanbul prosecutor lists 37 officials - The Times of India

    Provides specific names of Israeli officials targeted by the Turkish arrest warrants, including the defence minister and national security minister, adding detail to the geopolitical section.

  6. Turkish Judiciary Issues Arrest Warrants for Netanyahu, Ben Gvir, and Katz - Sada News Agency

    Confirms the issuance of arrest warrants by the Istanbul Criminal Court and quotes Israeli politician Avigdor Lieberman's reaction, linking the warrants to the debate over Turkey's potential role in post-war Gaza.

  7. Last living American hostage released by Hamas as Netanyahu plans for Gaza's reoccupation | PBS News

    This source, though dated May 2025, provides background on the release of the *last living* American hostage, Edan Alexander. This is crucial context to distinguish from the article's focus on the return of the *remains* of the last American hostage.

  8. Turkey issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Katz and Ben-Gvir over genocide charges

    Details the specific accusations in the Turkish arrest warrants, including attacks on hospitals and the killing of civilians, providing depth to the section on regional tensions.

  9. Israel and Hamas hand over bodies as part of Gaza ceasefire deal - The Guardian

    Outlines the core terms of the ceasefire deal, including the exchange of all living hostages for Palestinian prisoners and the subsequent exchange of remains. It also highlights the difficulties in identifying remains in Gaza.

  10. Israel says Hamas handed over additional remains believed to be of a hostage | PBS News

    Reports on the handover of hostage remains to the Red Cross as part of the ceasefire deal, specifies the date the truce began (Oct. 10), and mentions the reciprocal transfer of Palestinian bodies. It also notes accusations of breaches from both sides.

  11. Hamas to transfer remains of another Israeli hostage tonight under Gaza ceasefire deal

    Details Hamas's announcement of a specific transfer of remains, explains that the handover of all remains is a precondition for the second phase of the ceasefire, and notes Hamas's reasoning for delays.

  12. Israel Identifies Remains Of Returned Israeli-American Hostage | LIVE BLOG - i24NEWS

    Crucially identifies the returned American-Israeli hostage as Staff Sgt. Itay Chen, stating he was killed on Oct. 7, 2023, and was the last remaining slain American hostage. This is a core fact for the article.

  13. US plays down claims Hamas is violating ceasefire deal over hostage remains

    Provides the US perspective on the delays in returning remains, stating that the US government did not believe Hamas had broken the agreement and acknowledged the recovery could take weeks.

  14. Hamas transfers remains of Israeli hostage under Gaza truce deal - Yeni Safak English

    Confirms the transfer of remains via the Red Cross and reiterates that the return of all remains is a critical condition for progressing to the second phase of ceasefire negotiations.

  15. Edan Alexander, U.S.-Israeli hostage, released after more than 19 months in Hamas captivity - CBS News

    Provides background on the release of Edan Alexander, the last *living* US hostage, which helps to clarify the timeline and distinguish his case from that of Itay Chen.

  16. WATCH: American hostage returns to Israel from Gaza - YouTube

    This video report details the mechanics of a previous hostage release (Edan Alexander), including the role of the Red Cross and the transfer process, offering insight into how these handovers are conducted.

  17. Israel says returned hostage remains are those of seized soldier | International | Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha (BSS)

    Confirms the identification of Itay Chen's remains and provides powerful quotes from his parents, Ruby and Hagit Chen, about their ordeal and the need for closure, which are used in the article.

  18. The World Reacts to the Release of Hostages in Gaza

    Provides a summary of international reactions to previous hostage releases, including from the US, UK, and EU, which helps to frame the broader diplomatic context of the ceasefire.

  19. Hostages and Prisoners Exchanged as Israel-Hamas Ceasefire Holds - The Media Line

    Describes the emotional scenes and public reactions in Israel during hostage-prisoner exchanges, offering colour and human context to the events.

  20. Palestinian terror groups have violated Gaza ceasefire at least 18 times since implementation, IDF claims - Long War Journal

    Presents the Israeli perspective on the ceasefire, claiming that Hamas violated the agreement by not returning all slain hostages within the stipulated 72-hour period.

  21. Body of American Israeli soldier Itay Chen among those returned from Gaza - The Washington Post

    Confirms the return of Itay Chen's body and quotes his mother, Hagit Chen, on finding 'relief and peace for the soul,' which adds a crucial human element to the article.

  22. Hamas hands over body of presumed hostage to Israel, as 6 families await ID process

    Reports on a specific handover and notes that six deceased hostages remained in Gaza at that time. It also mentions that Hamas has previously returned remains that did not belong to any hostage, highlighting the complexities.

  23. Israel says another set of remains of a hostage has been turned over in Gaza | EverythingGP

    Provides details about the funeral of Israeli-American soldier Omer Neutra and the long campaign by his parents for his return, offering a parallel story to that of Itay Chen.

  24. Hamas continues to return hostage remains as Gaza ceasefire holds - Long War Journal

    Explicitly states that Itay Chen was the last remaining American hostage held in Gaza whose remains were returned. It also lists the names of other hostages still held at the time, providing context on the overall situation.

  25. Hamas hands over remains of another hostage to Red Cross - Xinhua

    Provides statistics on the exchange, noting that Hamas had released 20 living hostages and Israel had freed 250 Palestinian prisoners and about 1,800 detainees as of early November 2025.

  26. Hostage Remains Returned Amid Israel Hamas Ceasefire - Grand Pinnacle Tribune

    Gives biographical details about Itay Chen, describing him as a youth instructor and athlete, which adds personal depth to the narrative. It also mentions the eulogy for Omer Neutra by a US CENTCOM commander.

  27. U.S. steps up Gaza aid role to support fragile ceasefire - The Washington Post

    Summarizes the initial achievements of the Trump peace plan, including the ceasefire, release of living hostages, and withdrawal of IDF from parts of Gaza, providing a high-level overview of the agreement's status.

  28. Israeli-American captive Edan Alexander freed in Gaza, returning to Israel after US-Hamas talks - YouTube

    This source clarifies that the release of the last living American hostage, Edan Alexander, was the result of direct talks between the US and Hamas, highlighting the American diplomatic role.

  29. Gaza hostage remains to be returned on Friday night | The Jerusalem Post

    Describes the procedure for handling returned remains, specifying that they are transferred to the National Center for Forensic Medicine in Abu Kabir for identification.

  30. Meet the American Hostages Who Were Held Captive By Hamas After October 7 | AJC

    Confirms the date of Omer Neutra's remains being returned (November 2, 2025) and highlights the advocacy work of his family, providing specific details for the article.

  31. IDF receives casket from Red Cross in Gaza apparently holding body of hostage

    Details the handover process: Hamas gives the remains to the Red Cross, which then transfers them to the IDF. It also describes the ceremony conducted by the IDF upon receiving the casket.

  32. Israel receives body of murdered hostage from Red Cross in Gaza | Israel National News

    Provides an official statement from the Israeli Prime Minister's Office confirming the receipt of a coffin via the Red Cross and outlining the subsequent steps, including the transfer to the forensic center and notification of the family.

  33. Body of hostage returned by Islamic Jihad, transferred to Israel for identification - Ynetnews

    Lists the names of the six hostages whose bodies were still believed to be in Gaza at the time of the report, providing specific context on the remaining missing individuals.

  34. Hamas returns another Israeli hostage remains under Gaza ceasefire deal - Anadolu Ajansı

    Confirms a specific handover of remains found in Khan Younis and links to a separate report on Hamas hailing the Turkish arrest warrants, connecting the two events.

  35. As Gaza ceasefire hinges on returning remains, Waltz says U.S. to help find the missing, including Americans - CBS News

    Highlights the US position on the ceasefire, with officials urging patience regarding the return of remains and noting the difficulties involved in the recovery process.

  36. Gaza war hostage crisis - Wikipedia

    Provides a general overview and timeline of the hostage crisis, including the announcement of the peace plan and the initial release of living hostages in October 2025.

  37. Hostage remains returned by Hamas are those of Tanzanian student, Israel says - PBS

    Reports on the return of a non-Israeli hostage, a Tanzanian student, which illustrates the international dimension of the crisis. It also mentions the difficulty for Gazan health officials in identifying remains due to a lack of DNA kits.

  38. Remains of hostage Joshua Loitu Mollel returned | The Jerusalem Post

    Confirms the identification of Tanzanian student Joshua Loitu Mollel and notes that the return of Chen and Neutra marked the last of the Israeli-American hostages held by Hamas.

  39. Remains Released to Israel Belong to a Hostage, Forensic Experts Confirm

    Describes the confirmation by forensic teams following a transfer and reiterates the Israeli government's commitment to bringing home every hostage.

  40. Israel confirms identities of latest Gaza hostage bodies returned by Hamas

    Provides examples of other hostages whose remains were returned and identified, showing that the event described in the article is part of a larger, ongoing process.

  41. US tightens control over Gaza deal as Hamas stalls on hostage return - Ynetnews

    Discusses the diplomatic maneuvering around the ceasefire, suggesting Hamas is deliberately stalling and that the US has intervened to prevent escalation, which adds context to the fragility of the truce.

  42. Israel receives Gaza hostage body, prime minister's office says - Arab News

    A concise news report confirming a handover of remains and stating the number of deceased hostages returned at that point in time.

  43. Israel says another set of remains of a hostage has been turned over in Gaza

    Provides biographical details for Omer Neutra, including his upbringing in New York and his family's advocacy efforts, which are used to draw a parallel with the Chen family's experience.

  44. J STREET GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS NEWS DIGEST | November 7, 2025

    A news digest that contextualizes the return of the final American hostages' bodies within broader regional developments, such as the circulation of a UN resolution for an International Security Force.

  45. Text of the hostage-ceasefire agreement reached between Israel and Hamas

    Provides specific details on the exchange ratios and categories of prisoners involved in a previous phase of the ceasefire agreement, illustrating the highly negotiated nature of these deals.

  46. January 2025 Gaza war ceasefire - Wikipedia

    Offers a historical overview of a ceasefire agreement from January 2025, showing the recurring pattern of hostage-prisoner exchanges and temporary truces mediated by international actors.

  47. The Guardian's view on Gaza's future: the ceasefire brought relief, but the world must not look away now

    Provides analysis on the future of Gaza post-ceasefire, mentioning the difficult issues of forming an international stabilisation force and Israel's rejection of a role for Turkish troops, which is relevant to the conclusion.